---
title: "When AI powers the publication machine: What comes after publish-or-perish?"
author: Martin Ebner
date: 2026-11-16
url: https://postgenerative.at/indications/2026-11-16/when-ai-powers-the-publication-machine-what-comes-after
lang: en
type: Indication
summary: A theoretical article published under a pseudonym sees AI as the fulfilment and potential self-destruction of publish-or-perish. Four alternatives emphasize concrete contributions, open dialogue, lived research practice and diverse knowledge traditions.
tags:
  - Science
  - Research
  - Higher education
sources:
  - title: "Thomas Manabu (Pseudonym, 2026): The Machine Consumes Itself: Artificial Intelligence and the End of Publish-or-Perish. Postdigital Science and Education. DOI: 10.1007/s42438-026-00666-0"
    url: https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s42438-026-00666-0
license: CC BY 4.0 (https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/)
alternate:
  de: https://postgenerativ.at/indizien/2026-11-16/wenn-ki-die-publikationsmaschine-antreibt-was-kommt-nach
---

# When AI powers the publication machine: What comes after publish-or-perish?

Published on 9 June 2026, *The Machine Consumes Itself* advances a provocative thesis: Generative AI threatens the established order of academic publishing precisely by fulfilling its logic. A system that evaluates researchers through countable publications encounters machines capable of producing these texts with decreasing human effort. In the author’s view, publication counts consequently become less reliable indicators of research labour, judgement and scholarly recognition. [1]

### Why the existing configuration could reach its limits

The author identifies four connected pressures: AI facilitates plausible manuscript production; reviewing is increasingly AI-mediated; fabricated citations and compromised work can continue circulating through the literature; and human capacity for careful peer review does not expand at the same pace as potential text production. In this account, the problem goes deeper than individual misconduct: When the production of counted outputs becomes highly expandable, the basis for valuing those outputs becomes unstable. [1]

There is also a problem of scholarly formation. Reading, arguing, drafting, revising and reviewing are activities through which researchers develop disciplinary judgement. Systematically outsourcing them could widen access to finished texts while hollowing out participation in scholarly practice. The author acknowledges AI’s reduction of language barriers but distinguishes this from developing independent disciplinary competence. [1]

### Four possible directions for postgenerative scholarship

The author describes his alternative as a *postdigital scholarly commons*. He sketches four directions, rather than a complete or already validated solution:

1. **Recognize concrete contributions.** Scholarship should be acknowledged through a broader range of activities: maintained datasets, documented models, supported code, authored protocols, sustained teaching and public engagement. Recognition should rest on traceable contributions to practice; another single metric should not simply replace article counts.
2. **Build open dialogue networks.** Open peer review, post-publication discussion, registered reports and public commentary could make evaluation more accountable. Recognition would emerge through reasoned, traceable engagement rather than solely through a closed acceptance verdict.
3. **Strengthen situated and embodied knowledge practices.** Seminars, workshops, vivas, conference exchanges, mentoring, fieldwork and laboratory life anchor knowledge in people, places and shared activity. Their limited scalability is a strength in the author’s argument: Judgement develops and becomes visible through participation.
4. **Recognize diverse knowledge traditions.** Through *pluriversal epistemologies*, the author calls for space for ways of knowing marginalized by globally imposed publication and citation norms with Euro-American institutional origins. The aim is broader recognition, rather than merely rebuilding the same hierarchy. [1]

### Anonymity and scope

**“Thomas Manabu” is a pseudonym.** An editor’s note dated 27 October 2026 states that the author wishes to remain anonymous and that the journal and publisher know the author’s identity. It does not explain the reason for anonymity. [1]

This peer-reviewed article develops a structural, critical-theoretical argument using existing literature; it generates or analyses no original datasets. Its diagnosis and predictions should therefore be read as the author’s position. They establish neither that every AI-assisted publication lacks value nor that scholarship itself must end. The target is a configuration that distributes and rewards scholarly standing primarily through publication counts. The author also acknowledges institutional resistance and the risk that the proposed alternatives could be captured by the same incentive structures. [1]

The article itself discloses AI assistance: Perplexity supported drafting, structure, literature suggestions and language revision. The author claims the intellectual argument and accepts responsibility for the content. The paper’s production thus forms part of the debate it opens. [1]
