When AI makes the dead speak: remembrance between comfort and exploitation
A study distinguishes three modes of digital resurrection: deceased stars as spectacle, the dead as voices for public causes, and loved ones as everyday companions. Its conclusion: consent, control and protection against exploitation must develop alongside the technology.
Generative AI turns the voices, images and messages people leave behind into new performances and conversations. In “Artificially alive,” Tom Divon and Christian Pentzold examine how these reconstructions reshape remembrance. Their New Media & Society article first appeared online in December 2025 and was published in the November 2026 issue. This is an exploratory qualitative case analysis, not evidence of therapeutic effectiveness. [1]
Three modes of postmortal presence
1. Spectacularization: the dead as stars. Deceased performers’ voices and likenesses are reconstructed for stage shows, films or national celebrations. One example is Ofra Haza’s digital appearance with Noa Kirel. Remembrance intersects with entertainment, technological display and marketing. The deceased can no longer determine their new performances or messages. [1]
2. Sociopoliticization: the dead as public voices. Victims of violence or premature death are made to “speak” for awareness campaigns, commemoration and political demands. In the US campaign The Shotline, a synthetic reconstruction of murdered student Joaquin Oliver’s voice addressed lawmakers. Even a cause considered just does not automatically resolve who may speak for the dead. [1]
3. Mundanization: the dead as familiar companions. Chatbots, synthetic voices and interactive avatars seek to continue relationships in everyday private life. The article discusses Michael Bommer, who worked with Eternos before his death to prepare a digital version of himself. His case also illustrates personal agency: an individual can help shape their future representation. That choice differs substantially from reconstruction by third parties after death. [1]
Conclusion: who makes whom keep working?
The authors use “spectral labor” to examine the use and monetization of digital remains. Voices, likenesses and emotional bonds can become resources for companies, campaigns and platforms. Comfort, tribute and exploitation may sit close together. Simulation does not overcome death; it creates a technologically mediated presence whose design depends on others. [1]
Outlook: safeguards, access and responsibility
The authors identify questions concerning personal identity, consent, postmortem privacy and third-party control. Multiple digital copies of one person pose further challenges. Unequal financial resources and unevenly available data could extend existing inequalities into digital afterlives. Maintaining reliable archives across generations is another concern. [1]
Regulation must consider whether digital remains are treated primarily as transferable property or as matters of postmortem privacy. That distinction shapes access, transfer and monetization. Ethical and legal safeguards must accompany development; the outlook also considers pausing experimentation to shape its consequences collaboratively. [1]
A central question for a post-generative society therefore follows: who decides which version of a person continues speaking with us after their death?
The article’s final two sentences capture this problem:
“The afterlife is no longer elsewhere; it is distributed across platforms and shaped by the interplay of data, desire, and algorithmic reconstruction. What we resurrect may not be what we remember, but rather, what technology renders back to us.”
— Tom Divon and Christian Pentzold, Artificially alive, “Conclusion and outlook,” final two sentences. [1]
This Indication is licensed under CC BY 4.0. The quoted original article has its own license: CC BY-NC 4.0.
Sources
This indication by Martin Ebner is licensed under
CC BY 4.0
Comments 0
Comments are moderated. New comments appear after review by the editors.
No comments yet.